Prisco’s NFL Draft 2024 grades for all 32 groups, together with greatest and worst picks: Commanders obtain solely A+

Speedy draft grades carry instant disdain from followers and others, however that is what we do.

We service that anger that sits inside you. So let it out as a result of listed below are my 2024 instant draft grades.

I name them instant draft grades as a result of you’ll be able to’t actually consider a draft for 3 years, which is one thing I do yearly. My 2021 re-grade is coming in mid-Could. However that is knee-jerk grading for this 2024 draft. It’s instant, which might be unfair to the groups and people of us that do them.

I am going to take the warmth — as I at all times do.

In my ebook, there have been 5 groups that had actually good drafts, the perfect of all of them being the Washington Commanders, who acquired my solely A+ grade. First-year normal supervisor Adam Peters, who came to visit from San Francisco, nailed his first draft, beginning with quarterback Jayden Daniels, who they took second general. He will probably be a star. Peters saved going after that, loading up on good, gifted gamers, lots of whom I preferred all through the method. Sure, my movie analysis performs into the grades.

The opposite groups that acquired “A” grades have been the Arizona Cardinals, Kansas Metropolis Chiefs, Pittsburgh Steelers and Los Angeles Rams. Kudos to these normal managers and scouting staffs. 

So dive in, go searching, get indignant, seethe after which do one essential factor: The draft actually cannot be graded for 3 years — so chill out. On to the 2025 NFL Draft. 

Arizona Cardinals: A

Finest Choose: Beloved the decide of operating again Trey Benson within the third spherical. That’s the proper space to take a again, and Benson was my top-rated again. He’ll give them a pleasant 1-2 combo with James Conner. 

Worst Choose: I did not love the decide of tight finish/H-back Tip Reiman within the third spherical. He is a brute in the case of blocking, so I get it, but when they wanted a good finish I assumed there have been higher choices.

The Skinny: The Cardinals had numerous ammunition with 12 picks and Monti Ossenfort used it nicely. I preferred numerous their picks, beginning with receiver Marvin Harrison Jr., who’s a much-needed, dynamic playmaker. They added a bunch of potential starters the remainder of the best way, giving this rising workforce numerous gifted gamers. In addition they added 4 defensive backs, which was a should. 

Finest Choose: Fourth-round defensive sort out Brandon Dorlus from Oregon has an opportunity to be an early rotation participant. He is not big at 6-3, 295, however he can push the pocket. He will probably be a steal within the Grady Jarrett mildew. 

Worst Choose: It is not that taking Michael Penix Jr. with the eighth general decide was a nasty transfer, however somewhat signing Kirk Cousins after which taking him was the unhealthy transfer. For those who preferred him a lot, do not signal Cousins. 

The Skinny: This draft will probably be all about how the Falcons play out the Cousins-Penix dynamic. They’d an opportunity to get a much-needed edge rusher in the event that they did not take Penix. Buying and selling as much as get defensive sort out Ruke Orhorhoro within the second spherical was questionable as nicely. They did add some good gamers in third-round edge Bralen Trice and Dorlus. 

Finest Choose: Fourth-round nook T.J. Tampa will show to be actually good decide. He can play the nook, however I additionally assume he can transfer inside to security. Versatility is big within the Ravens protection. 

Worst Choose: Fourth-round broad receiver Devontez Walker can run, however he’s inconsistent. If he will be extra constant and catch the ball higher, he will probably be a steal. For now, it is dangerous. 

The Skinny: The Ravens and normal supervisor Eric DeCosta are normally among the many greatest within the league in the case of drafting. This was a strong draft as common, filling a bunch of wants. First-round nook Nate Wiggins needs to be a long-term starter. He can cowl, however must work on tackling. 

Finest Choose: Third-round defensive sort out DeWayne Carter is a bit undersized, however he will probably be an excellent participant. They want rotation guys inside and he’ll fill that position early in his profession. 

Worst Choose: I did not love the decide of security Cole Bishop within the second spherical. I do know it helps to fill a necessity, however there have been higher choices on the board when he went. 

The Skinny: I like the best way normal supervisor Brandon Beane managed his picks, shifting down within the first spherical so as to add extra ammunition. They nonetheless ended up with an excellent haul for a workforce that wanted an inflow of gamers, beginning with second-round receiver Keon Coleman, a much bigger goal that was wanted. 

Finest Choose: Fourth-round tight finish Ja’Tavion Sanders from Texas has the talents to be a big-time cross catcher. He is not a blocking tight finish, however although he did not time nicely him the 40, he performs quick. 

Worst Choose: I like Jonathon Brooks as a participant, however why take a operating again within the second spherical with so many different wants? The pondering is to most likely assist Bryce Younger, however that they had different wants. 

The Skinny: They did not have a first-round decide — traded away within the Younger deal — however they nonetheless ended up with one by buying and selling as much as land receiver Xavier Legette within the first spherical. They then moved round within the second and third so as to add additional picks, which I preferred, and added good gamers like third-round linebacker Trevin Wallace and Sanders. Legette must be Younger’s go-to man. 

Finest Choose: Regardless that he wasn’t my high quarterback, getting Caleb Williams with the primary general decide may change the destiny of this franchise. He has all of the instruments to be a star and might be their first true star passer since Sid Luckman. 

Worst Choose: They took a punter within the fourth spherical in Iowa’s Tory Taylor. Why? There are one million punters on the market. Plus, that may be a luxurious decide for a workforce with solely 4 picks. 

The Skinny: Getting Williams and receiver Rome Odunze (ninth general) will give the Bears numerous firepower on offense. If Williams can seamlessly step in and be an excellent starter instantly, the Bears will push for a division title. It could have been powerful to mess this draft up with the primary and ninth picks within the first spherical, however I did not love what they did after that. 

Finest Choose: Third-round defensive sort out McKinnley Jackson has run-stuff expertise that may assistance on the within of their protection. He has the dimensions at 6-2, 325 to be an influence participant inside, however he must be extra constant. 

Worst Choose: Third-round receiver Jermaine Burton from Alabama has the instruments to be a big-time participant. However there have been reportedly some character questions on him. If he is targeted, he will probably be an excellent receiver. 

The Skinny: Duke Tobin has finished a pleasant job drafting for the Bengals and it is a good group — and might be an awesome one. The danger is first-round offensive sort out Amarius Mims, who has simply eight begins in his profession. He’s a boom-or-bust participant in my ebook. Taking Kris Jenkins and Jackson will assist offset the lack of D.J. Reader in free company. 

Finest Choose: Fifth-round receiver Jamari Thrash is an effective route runner who’s a bodily to present them a younger weapon so as to add to their group. He’ll make the workforce. 

Worst Choose: I did not love guard Zak Zinter, their third-round decide. He’s additionally coming off a damaged leg suffered final season. However the Browns do appear to know a factor or two about creating guards. 

The Skinny: They did not have a first-round decide — despatched to the Texans for Deshaun Watson — in order that they needed to wait till till the twenty second decide of the second spherical to make a decide. That decide was Michael Corridor Jr., a defensive sort out from Ohio State. He is an excellent participant. The remainder of the draft was simply OK. 

Finest Choose: Third-round offensive lineman Cooper Beebe can play wherever on the road, though I believe he will probably be an inside participant for Dallas. Beebe performed sort out at Kansas State. 

Worst Choose: I did not love the decide of defensive lineman Marshawn Kneeland within the second. He is an influence finish who performs laborious, however I believe that they had higher choices. 

The Skinny: I assumed the Cowboys had a strong draft. Buying and selling down and including an additional decide and taking sort out Tyler Guyton within the first was successful. He’ll begin as a rookie and has the instruments to take action. They added some good soccer gamers the remainder of the best way, guys like Beebe and Wake Forest nook Caelen Carson (fifth). It wasn’t splashy, nevertheless it was strong. 

Finest Choose: I really like fourth-round receiver Troy Franklin. He’s a participant who will add pace to the offense and he is becoming a member of former teammate Bo Nix, the Broncos’ first-round decide. I do not know why he went within the fourth as a result of he is higher than that. 

Worst Choose: It is not that they drafted Nix with the twelfth general decide, however somewhat why not commerce again and take him? Nix has expertise and Sean Payton is aware of quarterbacks, however this one will probably be enjoyable to look at. 

The Skinny: This draft will probably be outlined by how nicely Nix performs. If Nix is beginning for Payton in three years, will probably be an awesome decide. In any other case, Payton’s job might be tied to him. No less than they received Franklin within the fourth. Fifth-round nook Kris Abrams-Draine from Missouri has expertise. 

Finest Choose: Fourth-round safety-running again Sione Vaki was the captain of my Higher-Than workforce. He’s a troublesome, bodily participant who is usually a beginning security, but additionally a significant contributor on particular groups. He additionally has performed operating again.

Worst Choose: I will not say it is the worst decide, since I have never seen his tape, however taking Canadian participant Giovanni Manu within the fourth spherical is definitely the riskiest. He’s a large man at 6-8, 350 kilos, however performed towards lower-level completion. 

The Skinny: They landed probably the greatest corners within the draft within the first spherical in Terrion Arnold, then got here again and used a second-round decide on nook Ennis Rakestraw Jr. from Missouri. That is good drafting, addressing want with two gamers who will probably be starters sooner or later — one this season. I really like Vaki and sixth-round defensive sort out Mekhi Wingo has some good tape. 

Finest Choose: Second-round linebacker Edgerrin Cooper will repay in an enormous approach. He can fly and can add a ton of pace on the second stage for the Packers. 

Worst Choose: I did not love the decide of Jordan Morgan within the first. I do know they want line assist, extra for depth, however I’m not an enormous fan of Morgan’s sport.

The Skinny: The Packers do a pleasant job with the draft, and this one will give them some gamers who may begin as rookies. The Packers clearly drafted for want, touchdown Morgan, Cooper and second-round security Javon Bullard. Operating again MarShawn Lloyd will probably be a pleasant addition to the offense behind Josh Jacobs. Quarterback Michael Pratt within the seventh is a pleasant decide, even when he will not play apart from for damage. 

Houston Texans: C+

Finest Choose: Third-round security Calen Bullock is a rangy security who will give them depth this season, however will ultimately change into a starter. He can run. 

Worst Choose: I did not just like the decide of nook Kamari Lassiter within the second spherical. I believe there have been higher choices there when he went, guys like Mike Sainristil. He ran 4.64 at his professional day, which isn’t nice for a nook. 

The Skinny: After having an awesome draft final yr, I did not love this yr’s model. They did not have a first-round decide — traded to Minnesota — after which they picked a sort out in Blake Fisher (who will not begin) and two secondary gamers who most likely will not begin with their subsequent two picks. Exhausting to doubt Nick Cesario after final yr, however I’ll for this draft. 

Finest Choose: I really like the decide of receiver Adonai Mitchell within the second. He’s a tall, quick receiver who will give them a pleasant addition to Michael Pittman and Josh Downs. 

Worst Choose: I like third-round offensive lineman Matt Goncalves from Pittsburgh, however he went a spherical or two too excessive. He will probably be a backup early in his profession and would possibly find yourself being a guard. 

The Skinny: I preferred the Colts’ first 4 picks, however I’d have taken Dallas Turner at No. 15 somewhat than Laiatu Latu, the cross rusher the Colts took. Latu does fill a necessity. Mitchell would possibly find yourself being a steal. He’s massive and might run. The Colts had an excellent, strong haul. 

Finest Choose: I really like second-round defensive sort out Maason Smith from LSU. His talent set is spectacular. A torn ACL in 2022 set him again, however he began to appear like himself late final season. He will be dominant. 

Worst Choose: The knock is that they did not tackle edge till the seventh spherical after they took Myles Cole from Texas Tech. They’ve depth points there and that might present up if they’ve accidents to their starters.

The Skinny: I’ve been vital of Trent Baalke’s drafts up to now, however this was an excellent one. First-round receiver Brian Thomas Jr. provides them a game-changer on offense that they’ve lacked, whereas Smith is usually a beast up entrance. Buying and selling down and including picks on this draft and subsequent yr’s draft was a sensible transfer by Baalke. 

Kansas Metropolis Chiefs: A 

Finest Choose: I picked two as a result of they drafted two of my Higher-Than workforce members within the fourth spherical. They took tight finish Jared Wiley and security Jaden Hicks so as to add depth at two positions early of their careers after which they are going to be starters in a number of. 

Worst Choose: I heard they actually preferred sort out Kingsley Suamataia from BYU, however I wasn’t as excessive on him as others. He does fill a necessity they usually did not need to take him till the second, although it was rumored he may go within the first. 

The Skinny: The Chiefs had an excellent draft. They traded as much as get receiver Xavier Worthy within the first, then did the identical to take Suamataia within the second. Worthy will probably be a sport changer for Patrick Mahomes. Taking two of my Higher-Than workforce gamers makes this grade go up. 

Finest Choose: Fourth-round nook Decamerion Richardson from Mississippi State is an extended nook who can play man protection and can compete for enjoying time instantly. He is an excellent nook and the Raiders want one to emerge. 

Worst Choose: I believe tight finish Brock Bowers is an effective participant, however why take him while you took Michael Mayer final yr and he flashed massive time late final season? They’d different wants. This was a luxurious decide. 

The Skinny: They did not get an opportunity to take one of many high quarterbacks since they have been all gone, in order that they took Bowers. Like I mentioned, good participant, however wanted different positions. Oregon heart Jackson Powers-Johnson got here within the second, and he’s shifting to protect. I did not love fourth-round sort out Delmar Glaze. 

Finest Choose: Third-round linebacker Junior Colson reunites with faculty coach Jim Harbaugh and he will probably be a starter early in his profession. He’s a troublesome, bodily participant who can run and canopy in addition to play the run. 

Worst Choose: I did not love the decide of Alabama defensive sort out Justin Eboigbe within the fourth spherical. They’ve had bother stopping the run, and he is good towards the run, however that is excessive for him in my ebook. 

The Skinny: They took sort out Joe Alt within the first spherical with the fifth general decide, passing on taking a receiver to take action. Alt will play proper sort out, which will probably be an adjustment for him. It is a strong decide, somewhat than attractive. That is the Harbaugh approach. I believe second-round receiver Ladd McConkey can begin instantly. 

Los Angeles Rams: A

Finest Choose: I liked the decide of Washington State defensive finish Brennan Jackson within the fifth. He’ll carry a relentless model that may preserve him within the league for a very long time. He’s excellent for the Rams protection. 

Worst Choose: I did not love the decide of operating again Blake Corum within the third. They’ve an excellent again in Kyren Williams, who they received within the fifth spherical. They might have waited to take a again. 

The Skinny: They lastly had a first-round decide after not having one since 2016 and used it on edge Jared Verse. He fills a necessity and will probably be a troublesome, edge participant. They adopted that up by buying and selling as much as take Florida State defensive sort out Braden Fiske within the second. They gave up loads to get him, so they have to love him. Les Snead had one other good draft. 

Finest Choose: It was their first one, edge Chop Robinson. He did not have numerous sack manufacturing, however he can get after the quarterback. He has an explosive first step and helps fill a necessity with their two high edge gamers coming off damage.

Worst Choose: For my part, they actually did not have one. I preferred each one among their picks, however they gave up a 2025 third-round decide to take operating again Jaylen Wright. I do know he is quick, and we all know they love pace, however that is wealthy after taking De’Von Achane final yr. 

The Skinny: Many will query their first two picks — sort out Patrick Paul was the second-round decide — however not me. I really like Robinson and Paul was on my Higher-Than workforce. He won’t begin instantly, however Terron Armstead is up within the years and missed seven video games final season. They added a bunch of different good gamers. 

Finest Choose: The Vikings moved up within the first spherical to take cross rusher Dallas Turner. That was an excellent transfer. He will probably be a big-time rusher in Brian Flores’ scheme. Turner’s greatest pass-rushing days are forward of him. 

Worst Choose: I get the entire concept of discovering a quarterback, and touchdown J.J. McCarthy the place they did is sensible, however I do not love his sport. He simply shot up boards after the season, and I by no means noticed it. I assumed he can be a late first-round decide. 

The Skinny: Like all of the groups that took quarterbacks, their drafts will probably be outlined by how nicely they play. That is the Vikings with McCarthy. Even when Turner turns into a real star, which I believe he’ll, this draft is about McCarthy. Interval. In addition they traded numerous future picks to get McCarthy and Turner, in order that they higher be stars. 

New England Patriots: B- 

Finest Choose: Fourth-round receiver Javon Baker will assist the passing sport instantly. He’s already squawking about groups passing on him. I really like that angle — and he performs with it, too. 

Worst Choose: Third-round sort out Caedan Wallace from Penn State began for 4 years, however he was drafted a bit too excessive. Some groups assume he might need to go inside to protect. 

The Skinny: It would not matter what else the Patriots do within the draft, this one will probably be outlined by taking North Carolina quarterback Drake Maye with the third general decide. If he is a star, this draft will probably be particular. If not, it will not be. I like his sport, nevertheless it would possibly take time. The forged round him is not nice. 

New Orleans Saints: B+

Finest Choose: Fifth-round receiver Bub Means is an extended receiver who can run. With just a little polish when it comes to his route operating, Means can change into a pleasant addition to their offense in the case of the deep ball. 

Worst Choose: I truly preferred all their picks. I believe that they had an excellent draft. If I needed to decide one to query it might be nook Kool-Help McKinstry within the second spherical since he is coming off a foot damage. 

The Skinny: They addressed main issues with their first two picks, taking sort out Taliese Fuaga within the first spherical after which McKinstry within the second. Fuaga will probably be a plug-and-play starter, whereas McKinstry may begin. Means and fifth-round quarterback Spencer Rattler are good worth picks. 

New York Giants: B-

Finest Choose: It was their first one, receiver Malik Nabers. Some will say they need to have taken quarterback J.J. McCarthy in that spot, however I like taking the perfect receiver within the draft. Nabers will probably be particular. 

Worst Choose: I did not love the decide of security Tyler Nubin within the second. I believe there have been higher safeties obtainable after they took Nubin. 

The Skinny: The Giants made the choice to cross on a quarterback to take Nabers. They supposedly tried to maneuver as much as get Drake Maye, however after they did not they handed on McCarthy to take Nabers. Good transfer. The remainder of the draft was simply OK in my ebook, however regulate fourth-round tight finish Theo Johnson.  

New York Jets: B-

Finest Choose: Third-round receiver Malachi Corley will are available in and instantly assist the passing sport. He’s a robust participant after the catch. Aaron Rodgers needed to be pleased with that decide. 

Worst Choose: I did not like utilizing the fourth-round decide on operating again Braelon Allen. They’ve Breece Corridor and will have used it on possibly a good finish or an offensive lineman. In addition they took a again later within the draft. 

The Skinny: By taking sort out Olu Fashanu, the Jets did the proper factor. But it surely positive did not appear like an all-in transfer for Rodgers since Fashanu goes to possible sit for a yr. Corley will probably be a pleasant decide, however this wasn’t an awesome draft for instant assist. 

Philadelphia Eagles: B+

Finest Choose: Reasonably than panicking and buying and selling up, they stayed put and landed the highest cowl nook within the draft in Quinyon Mitchell within the first spherical. It was a bet that paid off. 

Worst Choose: Third-round edge Jalyx Hunt has some explosive skill, however he most likely went just a little larger than I’d have taken him. He’ll take a while. However the Eagles clearly know he’s a developmental participant. 

The Skinny: Basic supervisor Howie Roseman normally likes to commerce up on draft night time, however he kept away from that within the first spherical and it labored by touchdown Mitchell. He did commerce up within the second to land corner-safety Cooper DeJean. Actually, he made eight trades enhancing his fame because the dealer GM. The most effective factor is a workforce drawback in protection final yr possible received mounted with the primary two picks. 

Pittsburgh Steelers: A

Finest Choose: I really like the decide of third-round linebacker Payton Wilson. He might need some medical points, however the Steelers followers will come to like him and his model of play. He’ll begin early. 

Worst Choose: Taking heart Zach Frazier within the second spherical is a necessity decide, however I wasn’t as excessive on him as some others. However who am I to query the Steelers in the case of the middle place?

The Skinny: They took numerous high quality gamers, together with three offensive linemen of their first 5 picks. It began with sort out Troy Fautanu within the first after which received Frazier within the second and guard Mason McCormick within the fourth. Wilson and third-round receiver Roman Wilson will play early. 

San Francisco 49ers: C+

Finest Choose: Second-round nook Renardo Inexperienced fills a necessity and would possibly be capable of be their nook instantly. Inexperienced had only one decide in faculty, however he’s a playmaker and would slot in their scheme. 

Worst Choose: First-round receiver Ricky Pearsall will probably be an excellent participant, however I do not assume he’ll ever be a star. There have been higher receivers left after they took him late within the first spherical. 

The Skinny: The 49ers clearly are drafting for the long run with Pearsall within the first — or readying to commerce one among their starters, both Brandon Aiyuk or Deebo Samuel. Third-round offensive lineman Dominick Puni may develop right into a starter — most likely at guard. Inexperienced will probably be good worth, whereas fourth-round receiver Jacob Cowing might be a sleeper. 

Seattle Seahawks: C+

Finest Choose: It was their first decide, defensive sort out Byron Murphy. He has the instruments to be a dominant inside participant. He will probably be loads like Baltimore’s Justin Madubuike for Seattle. 

Worst Choose: I did not love the decide of tight finish AJ Barner within the fourth. There have been higher choices on the board at that spot in my thoughts, together with Jared Wiley, who was taken 10 picks later by the Chiefs. Barner can block, however Wiley can catch. 

The Skinny: Murphy will probably be a star, which can make this draft successful down the street. However the remainder of it was simply OK for me. I do like third-round guard Christian Haynes, who fills a necessity. 

Tampa Bay Buccaneers: B+

Finest Choose: Third-round receiver Jalen McMillan will show to be a significant steal. He was Washington’s main receiver in 2022, with extra catches than Rome Odunze, who went ninth on this draft. McMillan will change into an excellent slot receiver. 

Worst Choose: I did not love the decide of Chris Braswell within the second. I do know they want pass-rush assist, however this was just a little excessive for Braswell in my ebook. 

The Skinny: They did a pleasant job touchdown good gamers and in addition filling wants. It began with first-round guard-center Graham Barton, who will possible be the beginning heart. Braswell was picked for want and will probably be a rotation participant early. I do like McMillan and fifth-round operating again Bucky Irving. 

Tennessee Titans: B

Finest Choose: Fifth-round nook Jarvis Brownlee Jr. will probably be a nickel starter sooner or later in his profession. Brownlee is a smallish nook, however he can cowl.

Worst Choose: T’Vondre Sweat is a dangerous decide, particularly within the second spherical. He had a DUI earlier within the draft cycle and his weight was an issue at Texas. He must get in higher form or this will probably be a decide that backfires on them. He does have expertise. 

The Skinny: Getting sort out JC Latham within the first spherical will repay in an enormous approach. He will probably be their beginning left sort out for a very long time. The Swift decide is feast or famine. Brownlee will show to be a steal and sixth-round receiver Jha’Quan Jackson can fly and can assist the return sport. 

Washington Commanders: A+

Finest Choose: It was their first one, quarterback Jayden Daniels. I believe he would be the greatest quarterback from this draft. They locked up a franchise passer with decide No. 2. He will probably be dynamic. 

Worst Choose: I did not love the decide of third-round receiver Luke McCaffrey, though he has expertise and is bettering. I believe there have been higher choices on the board — like Troy Franklin — when the decide was made. 

The Skinny: In his first yr operating the draft, normal supervisor Adam Peters killed it. It began by taking Daniels with the second general decide, however continued all through the method. It is a workforce shifting in the proper course. I preferred all their second-round picks in defensive sort out Johnny Newton, nook Mike Sainristil and tight finish Ben Sinnott. They drafted numerous gifted soccer gamers.